| YEAR | PLAYER | POSITION | |
| 1890 | Scott Williams | QB | |
| 1891 | R. W. Hart | FB | |
| 1892 | R. W. Hart | FB | |
| 1893 | George H. Atherton | E | |
| 1894 | J.E. Pfeffer | T | |
| 1895 | Robert J. Hotchkiss | FB | |
| 1896 | Charles D. Beebe | G | |
| 1897 | Don Sweney | T | |
| 1898 | A. R. Johnston | FB | |
| 1899 | E.C. McLane | C | |
| 1900 | Arthur R. Hall | E-HB | |
| 1901 | Justa M. Lindgren | T | |
| 1902 | Garland (Jake) Stahl | T | |
| 1903 | Claude J. Rothgeb | G-E | |
| 1904 | C. A. Fairweather | G | |
| 1905 | C. J. Moynihan | T-HB | |
| 1906 | Ira T. Carrithers | HB | |
| 1907 | Lion Gardiner | HB | |
| 1908 | F. C. Van Hook | G | |
| 1909 | Benjamin F. Baum | E | |
| 1910 | G. D. Butzer | G | |
| 1911 | Chester C. Roberts | HB | |
| 1912 | William H. Woolston | FB-HB | |
| 1913 | Enos M. Rowe | FB | |
| 1914 | Ralph D. Chapman | G | |
| 1915 | John W. Watson | C | |
| 1916 | Frank B. Macomber | QB | |
| 1917 | Reynold R. Kraft | E | |
| 1918 | B. A. Ingwersen | T (Acting) | |
| 1919 | William K. Kopp | FB | |
| 1920 | J. C. Depler | C | |
| 1921 | L. W. Walquist | HB | |
| 1922 | David D. Wilson | E | |
| 1923 | James W. McMillen | G | |
| 1924 | Frank E. Rokusek | E-T | |
| 1925 | Harold E. (Red) Grange | HB | |
| 1926 | Charles E. Kassel | E | |
| 1927 | Robert Reitsch | C | |
| 1928 | Albert J. Nowack | T | |
| 1929 | Russell J. Crane | G | |
| 1930 | Olaf E. Robinson | FB | |
| 1931 | Gilbert Berry | HB | |
| 1932 | Gilbert Berry | QB | |
| 1933 | Herman Walser | FB | |
| 1934 | Charles Bennis
Jack Beynon | G
QB | |
| 1935 | Charles S. Galbreath | T | |
| 1936 | Elvin C. Sayre | C | |
| 1937 | Lowell Spurgeon | HB | |
| 1938 | James W. McDonald | C | |
| 1939 | Melvin Brewer | G | |
| 1940 | Thomas J. Riggs | T | |
| 1941 | Selected each game | |
| 1942 | James Smith | FB | |
| 1943 | Selected each game | |
| 1944 | Selected each game | |
| 1945 | Ralph Serpico | T | |
| 1946 | Mac Wenskunas | C | |
| 1947 | Art Duffelmeier | HB | |
| 1948 | Herb Siegert | G | |
| 1949 | Lyle Button | T | |
| 1950 | Bill Vohaska | C | |
| 1951 | Charles Studley | G | |
| 1952 | Alfred Brosky | HB | |
| 1953 | Robert Lenzini | T | |
| 1954 | Jan Smid | G | |
| 1955 | Selected each game | |
| 1956 | James Minor | C | |
| 1957 | Dale Smith | HB | |
| 1958 | Jack Delveaux | FB | |
| 1959 | Bill Burrell | G | |
| 1960 | Bill Brown | FB | |
| 1961 | Gary Brown | T | |
| 1962 | Bob Scharbert
Ken Zimmerman | T
HB |
| 1963 | Mike Taliaferro
Dick Deller | QB
G |
| 1964 | Dick Butkus
George Donnelly | C
HB |
| 1965 | Jim Grabowski
Don Hansen | FB
LB |
| 1966 | Bo Batchelder
Kai Anderson | E
C |
| 1967 | Ron Bess
Ken Kmiec | HBE |
| 1968 | Carson Brooks
Tony Pleviak | E
T |
| 1969 | Doug Redmann
Bruce Erb | G
LB |
| 1970 | Kirk McMillin
Doug Dieken | G
E |
| 1971 | Glenn Collier
Larry McCarren | E
C |
| 1972 | Larry McCarren
John Wiza | C
lb |
| 1973 | John Gann
Ken Braid | G
LB |
| 1974 | Ty McMillin
Revie Sorey | LB
G |
| 1975 | Dean March
Stu Levenick | DE
OT |
| 1976 | Dean March
Scott Studwell
Marty Friel | DE
LB
TE |
| 1977 | Kurt Steger
Rickie Mitchem | QB
W |
| 1978 | John Sullivan
Charlie Weber | LB
FB |
| 1979 | Lawrence McCullough
Stanley Ralph | QB
DT |
| 1980 | Dave Dwyer
Ron Ferrari
Dave Wilson | DT
Special Teams
QB |
| 1981 | Greg Boeke
Ron Ferrari
Jack Squirek | C
OLB
MLB |
| 1982 | Mike Bass
Dan Gregus
Mike Martin | K
DT
WR |
| 1983 | Don Thorp
Tim Brewster
Joe Miles | DT
TE
FB |
| 1984 | David Edwards
Rick Schulte | DB
OG |
| 1985 | Jack Trudeau
Craig Swoope
Chris White | QB
DB
K |
| 1986 | Scott Davis
Mark Dennis
Sam Ellsworth
Shane Lamb | DE
OT
LB
QB |
| 1987 | Mike Scully
Mike Piel
Darrick Brownlow | OG
DE
LB |
| 1988 | Glenn Cobb
Mark McGowan | S
OT |
| 1989 | Craig Schneider
Mike Bellamy
Steve Glasson
Moe Gardner | OT
WR
LB
NT |
| 1990 | Moe Gardner
Darrick Brownlow
Curt Lovelace
Howard Griffith | NT
LB
C
RB |
| 1991 | Tim Simpson
Marlon Primous
Mike Hopkins | OG
S
S | |
| 1992 | Brad Hopkins
John Wright
Steven Mueller | OT
WR
Honorary |
| 1993 | Greg Enge
Filmel Johnson
Gary Voelker | C
CB
WR |
| 1994 | Pete Gabrione
John Holecek
Dana Howard
Jon Kerr | LB/C
LB
LB
OG |
| 1995 | Jason Dulick
Kevin Hardy
Brett Larsen | WR
LB
P |
| 1996 | Rodney Byrd
Ty Douthard
Paul Marshall
Dennis Stallings | FB
RB
NT
LB |
| 1997 | Ivan Benson
Danny Clark
Robert Holcombe | S
LB
HB |
| 1998 | Ivan Benson
Danny Clark
Ryan Schau | S
LB
OL |
| 1999 | Danny Clark
Steve Havard
Ray Reziniak
Neil Rackers | LB
HB
OG
PK |
| 2000 | Muhammad Abdullah
Bobby Jackson
Ray Redziniak
Fred Wakefield | FS
SS
OG
DE |
| 2001 | Luke Butkus
Bobby Jackson
Kurt Kittner
Brandon Moore | C
SS
QB
DT |
| 2002 | Tony Pashos
Jerry Schumacher
Eugene Wilson
Walter Young | OT
LB
CB
WR |
| 2003 | Sean Bubin
Carey Davis
Derrick Strong | OL
FB
DE |
| 2004 | Kelvin Hayden
Duke Preston | CB
C |
| 2005 | James Cooper
E.B. Halsey
Ryan Matha
Pierre Thomas | CB
RB
DT
RB |
| 2006 | Alan Ball
E.B. Halsey
J Leman
Josh Norris
Pierre Thomas | CB
RB
LB
DT
RB |
| 2007 | J Leman
Rashard Mendenhall
Kevin Mitchell
Martin O'Donnell | LB
RB
S
OL |
| 2008 | Arrelious Benn
David Lindquist
Brit Miller
Juice Williams | WR
DT
LB
QB |
